Esta página todavía está en inglés. Las páginas principales ya están en español.
Iowa Supreme Court · No. 18-1534
In re 2018 Grand Jury of Dallas County v. John Doe
Decided February 14, 2020 · appeal from Dallas County · Government
What the court decided
AI summary A defendant challenged several rulings regarding a grand jury proceeding, including the state's ability to subpoena a defense expert and the rules for challenging the grand jury panel. The court addressed these legal questions through an interlocutory appeal. This decision determines which procedural rules and authorities apply during the grand jury process.1
The court’s own summary
On interlocutory appeal, John Doe challenges several district court rulings in a grand jury proceeding. Doe argues: (1) the State cannot lawfully subpoena a criminal defense expert, retained in anticipation of litigation, to testify at a grand jury proceeding; (2) the district court has the inherent authority to quash a grand jury proceeding; (3) a prosecutor who contacts an accused’s expert ex parte must be disqualified from the case; and (4) rule 2.3(2)(a) requires any challenge to the grand jury panel be raised and ruled upon before the grand jury is sworn.
Judges
- Trial judge: Dustria Ann Relph, Dallas County