District court, Judicial District 5
Dustria Ann Relph
District Judge · District 5B · Wayne County
About
Judge Relph, Wayne County, was appointed to the bench in 2014. She graduated from Iowa Methodist School of Nursing in 1988, Mercy College of Health Sciences in 2003, and Drake University Law School in 2006. Before her appointment, Judge Relph was in private practice with the Chambers & Relph Law…
Retention votes
| Election | Yes | No | Kept by |
|---|---|---|---|
| November 8, 2022 | 14,196 | 5,557 | 71.9% yes |
What lawyers said
Before each retention vote, the Iowa State Bar Association asks lawyers who’ve appeared before the judge to rate them from 1 (very poor) to 5 (excellent), and whether the judge should be kept.3
97% of 67 responding lawyers said to keep the judge (2022).
| Question | 2022 |
|---|---|
| Knowledge and use of the law | 4.63 |
| Sees the facts of a case clearly | 4.73 |
| On time for court | 4.84 |
| Listens to arguments and testimony | 4.69 |
| Runs the courtroom well | 4.72 |
| Temperament and manner | 4.90 |
| Clear, well-written decisions | 4.70 |
| Rules promptly | 4.75 |
| Uses technology to improve the courts | 4.74 |
| Avoids needless personal criticism | 4.76 |
| Decides on the law and facts, not outside pressure | 4.83 |
| Courteous and patient | 4.83 |
| Treats people equally | 4.86 |
| Fair to people without a lawyer | 4.78 |
| Said to keep the judge | 97% |
| Lawyers responding | 67 |
Source: Iowa State Bar Association Judicial Performance Review: 2022 (page 34).
Appeals from this judge’s cases
3 appeals on record; 1 reversed or vacated at least in part.4
- Criminal appeal No. 20-0464AI summary The defendant appealed convictions for second-degree sexual abuse, arguing there was not enough evidence and that the jury was given incorrect instructions regarding witness testimony. The Iowa Supreme Court vacated the previous decisions and sent the case bac…
- In re 2018 Grand Jury of Dallas County v. John DoeAI summary A defendant challenged several rulings regarding a grand jury proceeding, including the state's ability to subpoena a defense expert and the rules for challenging the grand jury panel. The court addressed these legal questions through an interlocutory appeal. …
- Criminal appeal No. 16-1525AI summary The dispute involved whether a driver's due process rights were violated when a jury was allowed to convict them based on the presence of any amount of a controlled substance in their system. The court of appeals found that the law was constitutional but decid…