Iowa Supreme Court · No. 22-1232
State of Iowa v. Kyra Rose Bauler
Decided June 28, 2024 · appeal from Plymouth County · Criminal
What the court decided
AI summary A driver appealed her felony convictions, arguing that the police lacked a valid reason to stop her vehicle and that subsequent searches of her car and purse were unconstitutional. The court reviewed whether the deputy had sufficient cause for the stop and whether the dog's actions or the search of the purse violated privacy rights.1
The court’s own summary
Following a bench trial, Kyra Bauler appeals her convictions for introduction of contraband, a class “D” felony under Iowa Code section 719.7(3)(a), possession of a controlled substance, a class “D” felony under section 124.401(5), and in a separate case, operating while intoxicated, first offense under section 321J.2(2)(a). Bauler appeals the denial of her motions to suppress arguing: (1) because the deputy did not have sufficient cause to stop her car, the stop violated her rights under the Fourth Amendment and article I, section 9 of the Iowa Constitution; (2) the K9 sniff of Bauler’s car violated her right against unreasonable searches because the dog physically trespassed on her cart in conducting the sniff; and (3) the search of her purse without a warrant violated her rights under article I, section 8 and the Fourth Amendment.
Judges
- Trial judge: Jeffrey A. Neary, Plymouth County
Iowa Code it cites
§124.401§321.285§321.294§321J.2§716.7§719.7§808.16
Each links to the bills that change that chapter.