Iowa Supreme Court · No. 22-1026

James R. Penny v. City of Winterset and Christian Dekker

Decided December 29, 2023 · appeal from Madison County · Government

What the court decided

AI summary A driver sued for damages after a collision with a police vehicle that was responding to an emergency call. The driver argued that the officer acted recklessly by driving through a stop sign, but the district court dismissed the case. The Iowa Supreme Court overturned a previous appeals court decision and upheld the district court's ruling to dismiss the lawsuit.1

Result: DECISION OF COURT OF APPEALS VACATED; DISTRICT COURT JUDGMENT AFFIRMED

The court’s own summary

Plaintiff appealed a summary judgment dismissing his action for damages caused by a collision with a police vehicle responding to an emergency call. Plaintiff contends the district court erred in failing to find a genuine issue of material fact existed as to whether the officer acted recklessly in driving through a stop sign. See Iowa Code § 321.231 (2020). The court of appeals reversed and remanded. Defendants seek further review.

Holding: The defendants seek further review of a court of appeals decision reversing a district court’s grant of summary judgment. DECISION OF COURT OF APPEALS VACATED; DISTRICT COURT JUDGMENT AFFIRMED.

Read the opinion (PDF) · Case page on iowacourts.gov

Judges

Iowa Code it cites

§321.231

Each links to the bills that change that chapter. Read chapter 321