Iowa Supreme Court · No. 22-0813

Timothy Duane Smith v. State of Iowa

Decided June 7, 2024 · appeal from Cass County · Criminal

What the court decided

AI summary The defendant argued that his lawyer provided ineffective assistance by failing to request more jury challenges, failing to report jury misconduct, and failing to call certain witnesses. The court of appeals had previously ruled in favor of the defendant, but the Iowa Supreme Court vacated that decision. This means the original district court ruling denying the defendant's claims stands.1

Result: DECISION OF COURT OF APPEALS VACATED; DISTRICT COURT JUDGMENT AFFIRMED

The court’s own summary

The State seeks further review of the court of appeals decision reversing and remanding the denial of Timothy Duane Smith’s postconviction application. The court of appeals found that trial counsel provided ineffective assistance of counsel in failing to request additional peremptory strikes resulting in not being able to raise error on appeal amounting to Strickland prejudice.

Holding: Appeal from the denial of postconviction relief for claims of ineffective assistance of counsel in conducting voir dire, failing to alert the court to jury misconduct, and failing to call favorable witnesses. DECISION OF COURT OF APPEALS VACATED; DISTRICT COURT JUDGMENT AFFIRMED.

Read the opinion (PDF) · Case page on iowacourts.gov

Judges