Esta página todavía está en inglés. Las páginas principales ya están en español.
Iowa Supreme Court · No. 22-0805
State of Iowa v. T.J.W.
Decided February 9, 2024 · appeal from Scott County · Criminal
What the court decided
AI summary The defendant challenged a court order requiring them to pay money to a victim after their criminal charges had already been dismissed and expunged. The defendant argued the court no longer had the legal authority to order such payments once the deferred judgment was completed. The court ruled in favor of the defendant, meaning the order to pay restitution was overturned.1
Result: WRIT SUSTAINED
The court’s own summary
The defendant was granted discretionary review of the district court’s victim restitution order entered after successful completion of a deferred judgment. The defendant argues the district court lacked subject matter jurisdiction and/or statutory authority to enter a restitution order for payment of the victim’s pecuniary damages after the successful completion of all conditions of the deferred judgment, dismissal and expungement. The defendant further argues the restitution order is not supported by substantial evidence.
Holding: The defendant appeals a restitution order for pecuniary damages entered after the court had already dismissed and expunged all charges on completion of a deferred judgment. WRIT OF CERTIORARI GRANTED; WRIT SUSTAINED.
Judges
- Written by Justice Matthew McDermott
- Trial judge: Christine Dalton Ploof, Scott County
Iowa Code it cites
§602.6306§901C.2§907.9§910.1§910.2§910.3§910.7
Each links to the bills that change that chapter.