Iowa Supreme Court · No. 22-0401

Senator Roby Smith, Senator Jim Carlin, Senator Chris Cournoyer, Senator Adrian Dickey, Senator Jason Shultz, Senator Dan Zumbach, Former Senator Zach Whiting, Rep. Brooke Boden, Rep. Bobby Kaufmann, Rep. Carter Nordman and Rep. Jeff Shipley v. Iowa District Court for Polk County

Decided February 23, 2024 · appeal from Polk County · Government

What the court decided

AI summary State legislators challenged a court order that required them to turn over communications with third parties regarding new election laws. The legislators argued that this order violated the separation of powers and the privacy rights of the public. The court ruled in favor of the legislators and blocked the subpoenas. This means the legislators do not have to produce those specific documents.1

Result: WRIT SUSTAINED

The court’s own summary

In this certiorari action, several nonparty state legislators seek review of the district court’s order compelling them to produce their communications with third parties about two recently enacted election laws. The legislators argue the district court breached the separation of powers by piercing legislative privilege to order the legislators to comply with a subpoena for legislative documents. The legislators further argue that compelling production of communications received by the legislators violates the public’s privacy interests and rights under article I, section 20, of the Iowa Constitution.

Holding: Nonparty legislators seek a writ of certiorari to quash subpoenas issued to them in underlying litigation challenging recent election legislation on the basis of a legislative evidentiary privilege. PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI GRANTED; WRIT SUSTAINED.

Read the opinion (PDF) · Case page on iowacourts.gov

Judges