Esta página todavía está en inglés. Las páginas principales ya están en español.
Iowa Supreme Court · No. 21-1211
State of Iowa v. Benjamin G. Trane
Decided January 6, 2023 · appeal from Lee County · Criminal
What the court decided
AI summary The defendant appealed a decision regarding whether an alleged victim had previously made false accusations of sexual abuse against their adoptive or foster parents. The court affirmed the lower court's ruling that the defendant failed to provide enough evidence to prove those false allegations occurred. This means the defendant's original convictions remain in place.1
Result: AFFIRMED
The court’s own summary
In State v. Trane, 934 N.W.2d 447 (Iowa 2019), this court conditionally affirmed Benjamin Trane’s convictions for assault with intent to commit sexual abuse; child endangerment; and pattern, practice, or scheme to engage in sexual exploitation by a counselor or therapist but remanded to the district court to conduct an in camera rule 5.412 hearing to determine whether victim K.S. made false allegations of sexual abuse against her adoptive or foster parents. On remand, the district court found that Trane failed to make this showing. Trane appeals from that order arguing the district court’s conclusion is not supported by substantial evidence. Trane further argues the district court abused its discretion in failing to recuse itself from the rule 5.412 hearing and committed clear error by conducting a rule 5.412 hearing contrary to the rules of evidence and this court’s decision in Trane, and by considering and giving undue weight to immaterial evidence.
Holding: The defendant appeals the district court’s conclusion on remand that he failed to show that an alleged victim had made false accusations of sexual abuse against the victim’s adoptive or foster parents. AFFIRMED.
Judges
- Written by Justice David May
- Trial judge: Mark Kruse, Lee County
Iowa Code it cites
Each links to the bills that change that chapter.