Iowa Supreme Court · No. 20-1346

Rodrigo Adolpho Amaya v. State Public Defender

Decided June 24, 2022 · appeal from Polk County · Government

What the court decided

AI summary The State Public Defender challenged a court order that found an Iowa law unconstitutional and required the state to pay for certain services for a defendant. The court sustained the writ, which means it upheld the lower court's decision. This means the state must provide the requested services at its own expense.1

Result: WRIT SUSTAINED

The court’s own summary

The State Public Defender appeals from a district court order granting the defendant’s motion for services at state expense and finding Iowa Code section 815.1 unconstitutional as applied under the Sixth Amendment of the United States Constitution. The State Public Defender argues the statute does not deny the defendant the right to counsel, the right to effective assistance of counsel, or the right to hire private counsel of choice. It further argues the statute does not deny the defendant due process of law or violate equal protection.

Holding: The State Public Defender challenges a trial court order finding Iowa Code section 815.1 unconstitutional under the Sixth Amendment to the United States Constitution and granting the defendant’s request for ancillary services at state expense. WRIT SUSTAINED.

Read the opinion (PDF) · Case page on iowacourts.gov

Judges

Iowa Code it cites

§13B.4§692A.103§775.5§815.1§815.7§86.1

Each links to the bills that change that chapter.