Iowa Supreme Court · No. 20-0445

State of Iowa v. Matthew Robert Sewell

Decided June 4, 2021 · appeal from Dickinson County · Criminal

What the court decided

AI summary The defendant challenged his conviction for operating while intoxicated, arguing that police violated his rights by monitoring and recording his confidential phone call with an attorney. He requested that the breath test results be excluded from evidence and that the charges be dismissed. The court affirmed the lower court's decision, meaning the conviction and the use of the breath test results stand.1

Result: AFFIRMED

The court’s own summary

Defendant appeals from the judgment and sentence entered on his conviction for operating while intoxicated (first offense). See Iowa Code § 321J.2 (2019). He contends the district court erred in denying his motion to suppress the results of his breath test from evidence. He argues: (1) he had a statutory right under Iowa Code section 804.20 to a confidential telephonic consultation with his attorney which law enforcement violated by monitoring and recording the conversation; (2) the monitoring and recording by police of his phone consultation with his counsel violated his rights under article I, sections 9 and 10 of the Iowa Constitution; and (3) the appropriate remedy is dismissal of the charges.

Holding: A defendant appeals the denial of his motion to suppress, claiming that he had a right to a confidential telephone call with an attorney before deciding whether to take a blood alcohol test. AFFIRMED.

Read the opinion (PDF) · Case page on iowacourts.gov

Judges

Iowa Code it cites

§321J.2§4.4§804.20

Each links to the bills that change that chapter.