Iowa Supreme Court · No. 19-2075

State of Iowa v. Mark Bernard Retterath

Decided May 6, 2022 · appeal from Mitchell County · Criminal

What the court decided

AI summary The State appealed a decision that would have given the defendant a new trial for solicitation to commit murder. This dispute arose because a witness refused to allow the court to review their private mental health records for potentially helpful evidence. The court of appeals reversed the order for a new trial, and the higher court affirmed that decision.1

Result: DECISION OF COURT OF APPEALS AFFIRMED; DISTRICT COURT JUDGMENT REVERSED AND REMANDED

The court’s own summary

Following a remand from the decision in State v. Retterath, 2017 WL 6516729 (Iowa Ct App. Dec. 20, 2017), in which the court of appeals conditionally affirmed defendant’s conviction of solicitation to commit murder but ordered an in camera review of the privileged mental health records of two trial witnesses for possible exculpatory information, the State appealed from a district court order granting defendant a new trial. The State contended the court erred in finding retrial was necessary because the court was unable to review the mental health records of one of the witnesses on remand due to the witness’s refusal to consent. The court of appeals reversed the district court’s ruling. Defendant seeks further review.

Holding: The State appeals an order granting the defendant a new trial on his conviction for solicitation to commit murder. DECISION OF COURT OF APPEALS AFFIRMED; DISTRICT COURT JUDGMENT REVERSED AND REMANDED.

Read the opinion (PDF) · Case page on iowacourts.gov

Judges

Iowa Code it cites

§622.10

Each links to the bills that change that chapter. Read chapter 622