Iowa Supreme Court · No. 19-1814
State of Iowa v. Christopher Craig Hawk
Decided December 23, 2020 · appeal from Wayne County · Criminal
What the court decided
AI summary The defendant appealed his conviction and a court order requiring him to pay restitution for a drug offense. He argued that he did not have the financial ability to pay the required amount. The court affirmed the lower court's decision, meaning the order for restitution stands.1
Result: AFFIRMED
The court’s own summary
Christopher C. Hawk appeals from his conviction following his guilty plea to possession with intent to deliver more than five grams of the controlled substance methamphetamine in violation of Iowa Code section 124.401(1)(c)(6) (2017). Hawk argues: (1) the legislature’s recent amendment to Iowa Code section 814.6 should not affect Hawk’s appeal as the offense and plea occurred prior to July 1, 2019, and he only appeals his sentence and there is good cause for allowing his appeal. Alternatively, Hawk asserts the court should treat his filings as an application for discretionary review or writ of certiorari and grant relief. Hawk further argues the district court erred in finding that he had the reasonable ability to pay for restitution as the record discloses no means for him to do so. The State assumes, without conceding, that State v. Damme, 944 N.W.2d 98, 105 (Iowa 2020) controls this case, and thus, the appeal can go forward despite the amendments to section 814.6. However, the State contends the court lacks authority to decide Hawk’s unpreserved and un-exhausted restitution claim, and the claim is without merit, under both old case law and S.F. 457, which is newly-enacted legislation regarding restitution in criminal cases.
Holding: The defendant appeals his restitution order. AFFIRMED.
Judges
- Written by Justice Dana Oxley
- Trial judge: Patrick Greenwood, Wayne County
Iowa Code it cites
§124.401§453B.1§453B.12§814.6§910.1§910.2§910.2A§910.2B§910.3§910.7
Each links to the bills that change that chapter.