Esta página todavía está en inglés. Las páginas principales ya están en español.
Iowa Supreme Court · No. 19-1278
Krystal Wagner, Individually and as Administrator of the Estate of Shane Jensen v. State of Iowa and William L. Spece a/k/a Bill L. Spece
Decided December 31, 2020 · Government
What the court decided
AI summary The family of a person killed by a Department of Natural Resources officer asked the court to clarify how state laws apply to their lawsuit for constitutional violations and wrongful death. The Iowa Supreme Court answered several legal questions sent by a federal court regarding whether certain state immunity laws and procedural requirements apply to these specific claims. This decision helps determine how much compensation can be sought and which court system must handle the case.1
Result: CERTIFIED QUESTIONS ANSWERED
The court’s own summary
Plaintiff’s decedent was shot and killed by defendant, an Iowa Department of Natural Resources officer, during an armed standoff. Plaintiff’s estate and his mother brought an action in federal district court asserting claims for violation of his federal and state constitutional rights, wrongful death, and loss of consortium. The United States District Court for the Northern District of Iowa granted in part and denied in part defendants’ motion to dismiss and certified the following questions of law to the supreme court: (1) Does the Iowa Tort Claims Act, Iowa Code chapter 669, apply to plaintiffs' constitutional tort causes of action?; (2) Is the available remedy under the Iowa Tort Claims Act for excessive force by a law enforcement officer inadequate based on the unavailability of punitive damages? And if not, what considerations should courts address in determining whether legislative remedies for excessive force are adequate?; (3) Are plaintiffs' claims under the Iowa Constitution subject to the administrative exhaustion requirement in Iowa Code Section 669.5(1)?; and (4) Are plaintiffs required to bring their Iowa constitutional claims in the appropriate Iowa district court under Iowa Code Section 669.4? Krystal Wagner, Individually and as Administrator of the Estate of Shane Jensen State of Iowa and William L. Spece a/k/a Bill L. Spece
Holding: A federal district court certified four questions of Iowa law in a wrongful death and loss of consortium case including damage claims under the Iowa Constitution. CERTIFIED QUESTIONS ANSWERED.
Judges
- Written by Justice Edward M. Mansfield
Iowa Code it cites
§4.13§668A.1§669.14§669.2§669.21§669.22§669.23§669.3§669.4§669.5§670.1§670.4§670.5§684A.1
Each links to the bills that change that chapter.