Iowa Supreme Court · No. 19-1008
Cornelius Davis v. Iowa District Court for Scott County
Decided May 8, 2020 · appeal from Scott County · Government
What the court decided
AI summary A person challenged a court order that required them to pay a fine for not attending a settlement conference in person. The person argued that local rules do not require a party to attend if their lawyer is present. The Iowa Supreme Court agreed to review the case to determine if the fine was properly imposed.1
The court’s own summary
Plaintiff filed a petition for writ of certiorari requesting review of a district court order imposing a monetary sanction for his failure to personally attend a settlement conference. Plaintiff contends: (1) the local rule under which the sanction was imposed does not require a party to personally attend a settlement conference when their counsel is present; (2) the rule is inconsistent with the Iowa Rules of Civil Procedure if it does require a represented party’s personal attendance; (3) the rule does not authorize the sanction; and (4) the district court applied the rule inconsistently in the circumstances of this case. The supreme court granted the petition.
Judges
- Trial judge: Mark R. Lawson, Scott County