Iowa Supreme Court · No. 19-0849

State of Iowa v. Thomas C. Casper

Decided November 20, 2020 · appeal from Cerro Gordo County · Criminal

What the court decided

AI summary The defendant argued that his conviction for operating while intoxicated should be overturned because an officer failed to inform him of his right to an independent chemical test. The court affirmed the lower court's decision, finding that any error regarding the warning was harmless. This means the conviction stands because there was enough other evidence to prove the defendant was operating the vehicle under the influence.1

Result: DECISION OF COURT OF APPEALS AND JUDGMENT OF DISTRICT COURT AFFIRMED

The court’s own summary

Defendant appealed from the district court judgment and sentence entered on his conviction of operating while intoxicated (first offense). See Iowa Code § 321J.2(1)(a)–(b) (2018). He contended the arresting officer violated Iowa Code section 321J.11 by failing to advise him of his right to an independent chemical test and the district court consequently erred in denying his motion to suppress the results of a breathalyzer test. The court of appeals affirmed, finding any error was harmless since defendant was convicted based on the “under the influence” alternative of section 321J.2(1)(a) as well as the “alcohol concentration” alternative of section 321J.2(1)(b), and substantial evidence supported the conviction under subsection (a). Defendant seeks further review.

Holding: A defendant seeks further review of a court of appeals decision affirming the denial of his motion to suppress based on a claimed violation of Iowa Code section 321J.11(2). DECISION OF COURT OF APPEALS AND JUDGMENT OF DISTRICT COURT AFFIRMED.

Read the opinion (PDF) · Case page on iowacourts.gov

Judges

Iowa Code it cites

§321J.11§321J.2§804.20

Each links to the bills that change that chapter.