Esta página todavía está en inglés. Las páginas principales ya están en español.

Iowa Supreme Court · No. 19-0734

State of Iowa v. Hannah Marie Kilby

Decided June 18, 2021 · appeal from Polk County · Criminal

What the court decided

AI summary The driver appealed a conviction for operating a motor vehicle while intoxicated, arguing that the court should not have allowed evidence regarding her refusal to take a breath test. The court affirmed the original decision. This means the conviction and sentence remain in place.1

Result: AFFIRMED

The court’s own summary

Hannah Kilby appeals from her conviction and sentence for operating a motor vehicle while intoxicated, first offense, in violation of Iowa Code section 321J.2, following a bench trial on the minutes of testimony. She contends the court erred in denying her motion in limine to prevent consideration of her refusal to consent to either the preliminary breath test or the Datamaster breath test. She argues, as applied in these circumstances, Iowa Code section 321J.16 served only as a punishment for the proper assertion of her right to refuse a warrantless breath test, which violated her substantive due process rights pursuant to article I, section 9 of the Iowa Constitution.

Holding: A defendant appeals her conviction for operating a motor vehicle while intoxicated, arguing that the district court erred by allowing evidence that she refused a breath test. AFFIRMED.

Read the opinion (PDF) · Case page on iowacourts.gov

Judges

Iowa Code it cites

§321J.16§321J.2§321J.8§321J.9§462A.14§755.4§804.20

Each links to the bills that change that chapter.