Esta página todavía está en inglés. Las páginas principales ya están en español.
Iowa Supreme Court · No. 18-1427
Heather Young, Del Holland, and Blake Hendrickson v. The Iowa City Community School District, Chris Lynch, LaTasha DeLoach, Brian Kirschling, and Paul Roesler
Decided October 18, 2019 · appeal from Johnson County · Government
What the court decided
AI summary A group of citizens sued a school board after the board refused to put a proposal to demolish a local elementary school on a ballot. The court addressed whether the school board exceeded its authority and whether the citizens had the right to sue for damages and other relief. The case involves disputes over how state laws regarding school property and election petitions should be interpreted.1
The court’s own summary
Plaintiffs appeal, and defendants cross-appeal, from portions of a district court order granting a summary judgment in plaintiffs’ action for injunctive relief and damages arising from defendants’ decision not to submit to the county election commissioner plaintiffs’ ballot proposal regarding the demolition of a local elementary school. Plaintiffs contend the district court erred: (1) in dismissing their claims under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 and 42 U.S.C. § 1985 by finding their constitutional rights had not been violated; (2) in declining to award them damages and other relief; (3) in finding defendants were protected by qualified immunity; (4) in its ruling on a discovery issue; (5) in declining to award attorney fees; and (6) in declining to rule that a favorable vote on plaintiffs’ ballot proposal will preclude demolition of the school. Defendants contend the court erred: (1) in finding the school board exceeded its authority in determining that the referendum petition was not “authorized by law” pursuant to Iowa Code section 278.2(1)(2017); (2) in ruling that a private right of action exists to enforce Iowa Code section 278; and (3) in interpreting the term “disposition” of school property found in Iowa Code section 278.1(1)(b).
Judges
- Trial judge: Sean W. McPartland, Johnson County
Iowa Code it cites
§274.1§277.4§277.5§277.7§278.1§278.2§279.11§297.1§297.22§297.25§362.4§364.2§372.11
Each links to the bills that change that chapter.