Iowa Supreme Court · No. 18-1366
State of Iowa v. Jane Doe
Decided May 10, 2019 · appeal from Polk County · Criminal
What the court decided
AI summary A person asked the court to clear their criminal records after the charges were dismissed. The district court denied this request because the person had not fully repaid the fees for their court-appointed lawyer. The person appealed, arguing that requiring this repayment before allowing record expungement is unconstitutional.1
The court’s own summary
Appellant appeals from a district court order denying her motion under Iowa Code section 901C.2(1)(a)(2017) to expunge the records of criminal charges brought against her in 2009 which were dismissed pursuant to a negotiated agreement. Appellant contends the district court erred in denying expungement based on her failure to repay the full amount of the attorney fees for her court-appointed counsel in the criminal case. Appellant argues that Iowa Code section 901C.2(1)(a)(2) violates the federal and state equal protection clauses in requiring repayment of court-appointed attorney fees as a prerequisite for expungement.
Judges
- Trial judge: Becky Goettsch, Polk County
Iowa Code it cites
§692A.103§815.9§822.9§901C.2§910.2§910.7
Each links to the bills that change that chapter.