Iowa Supreme Court · No. 18-0464
Robert F. Colwell, Jr. v. Iowa Department of Human Services
Decided February 8, 2019 · appeal from Polk County · Government
What the court decided
AI summary A dental provider sued the Department of Human Services after the department refused to grant a hearing regarding denied insurance claims. The court addressed whether the state is required to provide administrative hearings to service providers rather than just Medicaid members. This decision clarifies the rights of providers to contest payment rejections through the state's hearing process.1
The court’s own summary
The Department of Human Services (DHS) appeals from a district court ruling on judicial review reversing the DHS’s decision to deny petitioner a hearing to contest the rejection by Delta Dental, one of DHS’s managed care organizations, of his claims for payment for dental services he provided to Medicaid patients. The DHS contends the district court erred by failing to find: (1) Iowa Code section 249A.4(11)’s mandate to provide state fair hearings relates only to Medicaid members and not providers; (2) Medicaid providers are not authorized to bill Medicaid members for services not paid by DHS’s managed care organization; (3) DHS need not provide administrative hearings to providers like petitioner under the applicable administrative rules; and (4) petitioner is not entitled to attorney fees under Iowa Code section 625.29.
Judges
- Trial judge: Arthur E. Gamble, Polk County
Iowa Code it cites
§17A.19§249A.2§249A.3§249A.4§249N.5§514C.3B§625.29
Each links to the bills that change that chapter.