Iowa Supreme Court · No. 17-0637
State of Iowa v. Robert A. Davis
Decided January 18, 2019 · appeal from Muscatine County · Criminal
What the court decided
AI summary The defendant argued that his right to contact a lawyer or family member should have started when the officer decided to transport him to the jail for testing. The court of appeals ruled that this right does not begin until the person is actually arrested for operating while intoxicated. This means the breath test results were allowed to be used as evidence because the legal requirement to allow communication had not yet been triggered.1
The court’s own summary
Defendant appealed from his conviction for operating while intoxicated (second offense), contending the district court erred in denying his motion to suppress the results of a chemical breath test. Defendant asserted that his rights under Iowa Code section 804.20 to communicate with a family member or attorney were triggered when the officer elected to detain and, due to inclement weather, to transport him back to the jail for field sobriety testing. Defendant contended that, because the officer did not allow him to communicate with his attorney until after his arrest for OWI following the sobriety tests, defendant’s subsequent decision to submit to the chemical breath test was tainted and should be suppressed as “fruit of the poisonous tree.” The court of appeals affirmed, finding the statute was not triggered until after defendant was arrested for OWI at the jail. Defendant seeks further review.
Judges
- Trial judge: Gary P. Strausser, Muscatine County
Iowa Code it cites
Each links to the bills that change that chapter.