Iowa Supreme Court · No. 17-0423

Keith Puntenney, Laverne I. Johnson, Richard R. Lamb, Marian D. Johnson, Northwest Iowa Landowners Association, Iowa Farmland Owners Association, Inc., and the Sierra Club Iowa Chapter, Appellants, v. Iowa Utilities Board, Appellee, and Office of Consumer Advocate and The Main Coalition, Appellees, and Dakota Access, LLC, Appellee.

Decided May 31, 2019 · appeal from Polk County · Government

What the court decided

AI summary Petitioners challenged a decision by the Iowa Utilities Board that allowed a company to build a hazardous liquid pipeline. The dispute focused on whether the board had the authority to decide if the pipeline served a public necessity and whether the company could legally use eminent domain to take land. The court reviewed these challenges to the board's permit approval and the use of land acquisition powers.1

The court’s own summary

The district court denied petitions for judicial review of the Iowa Utilities Board’s (IUB) decision to grant a permit to Dakota Access, LLC, for the construction of a hazardous liquid pipeline pursuant to Iowa Code ch. 479B. On appeal, the petitioners argue the district court erred in affording the IUB the authority to define the term “public convenience and necessity” under Iowa Code § 479B.9 and in affirming the IUB’s determination that the pipeline would promote public convenience and necessity. The appellants further argue Dakota Access’ exercise of eminent domain violated the Iowa and United States Constitutions, as well as Iowa Code §§ 6A.21 and 6A.22.

Read the opinion (PDF) · Case page on iowacourts.gov

Judges

Iowa Code it cites

§17A.19§414.11§479B.1§479B.16§479B.7§479B.9§6A.21§6A.22§6A.4

Each links to the bills that change that chapter.