Iowa Supreme Court · No. 16-0435
City of Cedar Rapids v. Marla Marie Leaf
Decided August 31, 2018 · appeal from Linn County · Government
What the court decided
AI summary A driver challenged a fine issued by an automated traffic enforcement system, arguing that the city's program was unconstitutional and violated state law. The court of appeals upheld the fine and rejected these legal arguments. This means the city's automated traffic enforcement system remains legal and enforceable.1
The court’s own summary
The appellant seeks further review after the court of appeals affirmed the assessment of a civil fine for her violation of section 61.138 of the Cedar Rapids Municipal Code, the City’s automated traffic enforcement (ATE) ordinance. The court of appeals rejected the appellant’s arguments that the ATE system is unconstitutional under the Equal Protection, Privileges and Immunities, and Due Process Clauses of the Iowa Constitution, is in violation of and preempted by Iowa law, and constitutes an unlawful delegation of police power.
Judges
- Trial judge: Patrick R. Grady, Linn County
Iowa Code it cites
§364.22§602.6101§61.138§64.138
Each links to the bills that change that chapter.