Iowa Supreme Court · No. 16-0267
State of Iowa v. Michael Scheffert
Decided April 6, 2018 · appeal from Black Hawk County · Criminal
What the court decided
AI summary The state appealed a decision that overturned a person's conviction for marijuana possession. The lower court found that because there was no proof a local ordinance had been properly adopted, the officer's decision to stop the individual was based on a mistake of law. This decision means the stop was unconstitutional and could not be used to justify the arrest.1
The court’s own summary
The State is seeking further review after the court of appeals reversed the appellant’s conviction for possession of marijuana and remanded for further proceedings. The court of appeals determined that because it did not have any evidence the ordinance the appellant allegedly violated had been properly adopted by the conservation board, it must be assumed that the officer made a mistake of law when making the stop. The court further found a mistake of law cannot justify a stop under article I, section 8 of the Iowa Constitution. State v. Coleman, 890 N.W.2d 284 (Iowa 2017).
Judges
Iowa Code it cites
§124.401§331.305§350.10§350.5§461A.46§622.62§805.8B
Each links to the bills that change that chapter.