Bills › 88th General Assembly
Where it is now
- Done: IntroducedFebruary 28, 2019
- Done: SubcommitteeJanuary 31, 2019
- Done: Senate committeeFebruary 28, 2019
- Done: Passes the SenateApril 10, 201949–0
- Skipped: House committeeSkipped
- Done: Passes the HouseMarch 21, 2019
- Done: To the GovernorApril 29, 2019
- Done: Signed into lawMay 1, 2019
HF 591 became law → The same legislation passed as HF 591, so this version was set aside. Go to HF 591 What’s a funnel?
What’s in it
This bill provides the basis for appointment of a guardian for a minor by the juvenile court, the procedures for establishment of a minor guardianship, and court monitoring and administration of minor guardianships. JUVENILE COURT JURISDICTION OVER MINOR GUARDIANSHIPS. Code chapter 633 contains provisions relating to guardianships, which apply to adults and minors. The bill repeals and amends the provisions that specifically refer to minor guardianships and replaces them with new Code chapter 232D, the Iowa minor guardianship proceedings Act.
Read the full explanation
The bill provides that the juvenile court shall have exclusive jurisdiction over minor guardianship proceedings. The effect of this provision is to transfer jurisdiction over these proceedings from the probate court to the juvenile court. BASIS FOR APPOINTMENT OF GUARDIAN. _____ to the establishment of a guardianship. The bill provides that a guardianship may be established without parental consent under the following circumstances: there is a person serving as a de facto guardian; there has been a demonstrated lack of parental participation in the life of the minor; and the appointment of a guardian is in the best interest of the minor. The bill also provides that a guardianship may be established if no parent is willing or able to exercise the power the court is requested to grant to the proposed guardian, and the appointment of a guardian is in the best interest of the minor. ESTABLISHING A GUARDIANSHIP. The bill contains provisions relating to the establishment of minor guardianships. These provisions specify the requirements regarding the contents of a minor guardianship petition, notice, and hearing. The bill provides that the court may appoint an attorney for the minor if the court determines that the interests of the minor are, or may be, inadequately represented. The bill also provides that the court shall appoint an attorney for a parent if the parent objects to the appointment of a guardian and the court determines that the parent is unable to pay for an attorney. The bill provides that the court may appoint a court visitor to visit the minor and other parties to the proceeding and gather the information needed by the court in determining whether to grant the petition. The bill retains the existing standard for appointment of a person as a guardian, namely that the person be qualified, suitable, and willing to serve in that capacity. Current law does not require background checks of proposed guardians. The bill requires that proposed guardians, other than financial institutions, undergo Iowa criminal record checks and checks of the Iowa child abuse, dependent adult abuse, and sex offender registries. _____ agencies, shall establish procedures for electronic access to the single contact repository for the conduct of background checks for a minimal fee. The bill gives the judge discretion to evaluate the relevance of any negative background check information in determining the suitability of a person for appointment as a guardian. The bill authorizes the emergency appointment of a temporary guardian. The court is authorized to issue an ex parte order appointing a temporary guardian on an emergency basis under limited circumstances. ORDER APPOINTING GUARDIAN AND GUARDIAN’S POWERS, DUTIES, AND RESPONSIBILITIES. The bill contains provisions relating to the order appointing the guardian and the guardian’s powers, duties, and responsibilities. The bill specifies the powers that the court may grant to a guardian. The bill sets forth the specific powers that the guardian may exercise without prior court approval and those powers that the guardian may exercise only with prior court approval. The bill also specifies the duties and responsibilities of the guardian. COURT MONITORING AND ADMINISTRATION OF MINOR GUARDIANSHIPS. The bill contains provisions relating to ongoing court monitoring of minor guardianship and administration of minor guardianships. The court has an ongoing responsibility to monitor minor guardianships in order to ensure the well-being and protection of minors subject to guardianship and the accountability of the persons appointed to serve as guardians. The bill provides that guardians shall file an initial care plan for the minor within 60 days of appointment for review and approval by the court. The bill retains the existing requirement that guardians file thereafter an annual report describing the minor’s status and needs and the guardian’s activities. The bill authorizes the court to remove a guardian and appoint a successor guardian under certain circumstances. _____ or terminate a guardianship under certain circumstances. EXPENSES. The bill provides that the court shall inquire into the ability of the minor or the minor’s parent to pay expenses incurred pursuant to the guardianship proceedings. After giving the minor and the parent a reasonable opportunity to be heard, the court may order the minor or the parent to pay all or part of the following: costs of legal expenses of the minor and the parent; expenses for a court visitor; and filing fees and other court costs, unless the costs are waived for good cause shown. The bill provides that if the court finds a minor’s parents to be indigent or if the minor has no parent, costs shall be assessed against the county in which the proceeding is pending. The minor or the minor’s parents are indigent if the minor’s or the parent’s income and resources do not exceed 150 percent of the federal poverty level, or the minor’s parent would be unable to pay such costs without prejudicing the parent’s ability to provide economic necessities for the parent or the parent’s dependents. EFFECTIVE DATE AND APPLICABILITY. The bill takes effect January 1, 2020, and applies to all minor guardianships and guardianship proceedings established or pending before, on, or after January 1, 2020.
Changed since by amendments S-3149, S-3146, H-1054; see Amendments.
Senate subcommittee
Named January 31, 2019. On February 21, 2019 it recommended passage.
Three legislators hear a bill first and recommend what the committee should do; it’s the best time to weigh in. How to take part
Fiscal note
AI summary This bill changes how minor guardianships are handled by moving them from probate court to juvenile court and requiring criminal background checks for proposed guardians. The Judicial Branch is estimated to spend $596,000 for three additional District Associate Judges and approximately $47,000 for Clerk of Court staff time. The Department of Public Safety may need an additional full-time Clerk Specialist, but this position would be funded through new background check fee revenue.2
Read the fiscal note
Description
House File 591 provides the basis for appointment of a guardian for a minor by the juvenile court, the procedures for establishment of a minor guardianship, and court monitoring and administration of minor guardianships. The Bill also provides that the juvenile court shall have exclusive jurisdiction over minor guardianship proceedings. The effect of this provision is to transfer jurisdiction over these proceedings from the probate court to the juvenile court. In addition, HF 591 requires that proposed guardians, other than financial institutions, undergo Iowa criminal record checks and checks of the Iowa child abuse, dependent adult abuse, and sex offender registries.
Background
As of January 1, 2019, there were 15,235 guardianship cases pending statewide, 57.0% of which involved minors. Under current law, the district probate court has jurisdiction over the minor guardianship proceedings. District Court Judges have general trial jurisdiction, including probate court, and Associate Juvenile and District Associate Judges have jurisdiction over juvenile court cases. Currently, there are 116 District Court Judges, 69 District Associate Judges, and 5 Associate Juvenile Judges.
Assumptions
- Approximately 8,864 minor guardianship cases will transfer from the probate court to the juvenile court.
- The salary and benefits for one District Associate Judge is $198,802.
- The cost of Clerk of Court staff time per hour is approximately $32.25.
- The estimated average number of minutes per year judges spend on a guardianship case is 30 minutes, with a per year total of 260,519 minutes.
- The estimated minutes per case that Clerk of Court staff will spend locating each existing guardianship case, electronically assigning it to a District Associate Judge or Associate Juvenile Judge, and informing the District Associate Judge or Associate Juvenile Judge of the case assignment is 10 minutes, with a total of 1,447 staff hours spent statewide.
- The background check requirement established in this Bill would increase the volume of criminal history record checks through the Division of Criminal Investigation (DCI) of the Department of Public Safety (DPS) by at least 12,000 per year. The criminal history record checks would be conducted through existing processes.
- Background checks cost $15 for each last name.
Fiscal Impact
House File 591 is estimated to have a fiscal impact on the operating budget of the Judicial Branch. The Judicial Branch estimates that the change in jurisdiction would have two impacts: 1) The change in jurisdiction would generate a need for three more District Associate Judges to cover the workload shift from probate to juvenile court. The cost of salary and benefits for three District Associate Judges would be $596,000. The Judicial Branch estimates that although there would be a decreased need for District Court Judges with the shift in jurisdiction, the Judicial Branch would require more judges to meet the recommended caseload formula per judge.
2) The Clerk of Court staff time required to transfer documents to juvenile court would cost the Judicial Branch approximately $47,000.
In addition, HF 591 may have a workload impact on the DPS. Based on the number of pending minor guardianship cases, it is estimated that the DPS would require an additional full-time Clerk Specialist to process the additional volume of background checks. This position would be fully funded through fee revenue generated from the increased volume of background checks. Any additional fee revenue would provide further funding to the background check system.
Sources
- Judicial Branch
- Department of Public Safety
- LSA calculations
- Final Fiscal Note - Minor Guardianships · June 4, 2019
- Minor Guardianships · March 12, 2019
- Minor Guardianships · March 11, 2019
Iowa Code it changes
Creates§232D.101§232D.102§232D.103§232D.104§232D.105§232D.106§232D.201§232D.202§232D.203§232D.204§232D.301§232D.302§232D.303§232D.304§232D.305§232D.306§232D.307§232D.308§232D.309§232D.310§232D.311§232D.401§232D.402§232D.403§232D.501§232D.502§232D.503§232D.504§232D.505
Amends§232.101A§232.104§235A.15§235B.6§602.7101§602.8102§633.10§633.552§633.554§633.557§633.561§633.635§633.675§633.679
Repeals§633.559
Lobbying
8 for · 2 against · 16 undecided · Who →
Family tree
88th General Assembly